Final ITC ruling in Samsung v Apple patent case delayed until February

Back in September 2012, U.S. International Trade Commission Judge James Gildea issued a ruling in one of the many Samsung v Apple cases, finding Apple had not infringed on four Samsung patents being contested in the complaint. Judge Gildea also found Samsung had engaged in a pattern of patent abuse in using their FRAND patents to stifle competition by seeking sales injunctions as part of their legal strategy. Since then, Judge Gildea has been working on finalizing the ruling, including presenting it to the full commission for approval. Until recently, the date for that final action was thought to be January 14th. A notice from the ITC indicates the commission will not take up the matter until February 6th.

Any time a schedule change occurs in court matters, it leads to speculation by different parties regarding the reason for the new delay. In this case, many are pointing to action Samsung took last month to drop all injunction requests related to their FRAND lawsuits in Europe. In addition to the U.S., Samsung is also being investigated in Europe regarding similar accusations of using their FRAND patents for anti-competitive purposes. Some observers assume Samsung took their action in the European courts in order to avoid hefty fines.

Apple took note of Samsung’s move as well and proceeded to file a Notice of New Facts with Judge Gildea. That filing was made only ten days ago and appears to be the reason for the delay as Judge Gildea considers the significance, if any, of the new facts.

source: electronista
via: PhoneArena

About the Author: Jeff Causey

Raised in North Carolina, Jeff Causey is a licensed CPA in North Carolina. Jeff's past Android devices include an HTC EVO, a Samsung Note II, an LG G3, and a Motorola Moto X Pure Edition along with a Samsung Galaxy Tablet 10.1. He currently uses a Samsung Galaxy S8 and (very rarely) a Nexus 7 (2013). He is also using a Verizon-branded Motorola Moto Z Play Droid supplied by his job. Jeff used to have a pair of Google Glass and a Moto 360 Sport in his stable of gadgets. Unfortunately, his kids have all drunk the Apple Kool-Aid and have i-devices. Life at home often includes demonstrations of the superiority of his Android based devices. In his free time, Jeff is active an active runner usually training for his next marathon, owns a MINI Cooper, and plays Dungeons & Dragons. Jeff has three mostly grown kids and a golden retriever.