Did Samsung Copy The Rounded-Corner iRectangle?

 

 

As the Apple vs Samsung trial starts here in San Jose, California, neither side is backing down from the fight. Samsung’s Chief Product Officer Kevin Packingham had some words that pretty much sum up his thoughts on the whole scene. It all comes down to fighting over rectangles. Here’s what he said during an interview with Wired.

“In terms of patents, we have a made lot of contributions in the design space as well. I would say the patents we’re struggling with — where there’s a lot of discussion and litigation right now — are around these very broad design patents like a rectangle. For us, it’s unreasonable that we’re fighting over rectangles, that that’s being considered as an infringement, which is why we’re defending ourselves.”

If we ignore all the legal detail surrounding the myriad of lawsuits between the two companies, and take a huge step back for a very wide point of view, it’s not impossible to boil the whole thing down to “Your thing looks too much like my thing!” and that’s what Packingham is essentially saying… that Apple and Samsung are at odds over a basic geometric shape.

Should a company be able to patent a shape? Obviously, hardware and software-wise, the two company’s devices are very different. But the general shape of a rounded-corner rectangle is common to both, so should that be allowed? You could also say that a particular Honda has the same shape as a particular Toyota, or that this Logitech mouse is shaped just like that Microsoft one. Personally, and perhaps obviously, I am totally on Samsung’s side on this one. Apple has a lot to lose since they have all their eggs in one iOS basket, so it makes sense they would defend it with all their power. But you’ve got to think somewhere inside the halls of Cupertino, someone is saying quietly to themselves, “Wow, I hope we get away with this.

source: wired


About the Author: Ed Caggiani

Originally from the East Coast, Ed now makes his home in San Jose, California. His passion for technology started with his first ColecoVision and Atari gaming systems, and has grown stronger through Tandy computers, IBM clones, Palm Pilots, and PocketPCs. Ed's love for Android began with his first HTC Hero, then blossomed with the original Evo 4G, and now the Evo 3D and Motorola Xoom. He graduated from Syracuse University with a B.S. in Communications, and is now a professional User Experience Designer working in Silicon Valley. In his spare time, Ed enjoys video games, jamming on guitar, and spending time with his wife, two cats, and Logitech Revue.


  • Jed Dignazio

    I hate mother******* Apple!!!

    • McHale72

      I wouldn’t say that too loud. After Apple sues every company on Earth, they are going to start suing non-customers for hurting their profit margins by not buying their products. In fact, we shouldn’t even be talking about this. The know where we live and they will…

      –END OF TRANSMISSION–

  • Jasper

    Apple u motherfu***** hypocrites ….all u do is sue for a lame damn thing .corners? Its a gud thing that they are not in other electronic appliances .

  • Bojo

    DAS IT, im going to eat a apple.

  • http://www.facebook.com/hdicaire HeeRa Dicaire

    Samsung AND Apple both copied the rounded-corner PADD from Star Trek. They even copied the smooth touch-screen concept from Star Trek! Plus Apple copied the PADD’s name and Samsung even took the Beaming name. Everything comes from Star Trek!