Latest Android news, applications and forum discussion

Jun

26

2010

iPhone 4 disguising caused antenna issues to go unnoticed? Think again.

12

by Dustin Karnes
tagged , , , ,

By this point, I’m sure you’ve heard all the stories going around about how the genius of Apple’s brilliant new antenna design on the iPhone 4 can be shattered by simply holding it. When you bridge the two antennas together on the top and bottom of the device, the bridge creates a major disturbance in frequency. And Apple’s response to it? “Simply avoid holding it in that way.”

According to an article over at the NY Times, it is possible, and even likely, that the issue was not caught before release because of a a couple key issues:

  • Apple’s HQ is obviously going to have wonderful reception, given the relationship between Apple and AT&T
  • Whenever the phone was taken into the wild, it always had a case on it to make it look like a 3GS

This writer’s opinion? Bad testing, coupled with pure laziness. The idea that a company could create this state-of-the-art new antenna design on speculation alone and not only neglect to consider the bridging of the two antennas, but also never test it the way it would be held without a case, is ridiculous.

What do you think? Let us know in the comments.

» See more articles by Dustin Karnes

Categorized as Android News

Comments

  • frustrated

    Just about ready to stop reading this site. Is this TalkAndroid or TalkiPhone4?

  • dh

    I don’t have an iPhone because AT&T service in my area is not very good. I would love to have one and I think what is ridiculous is that anyone would have a phone covered in glass, and NOT have it in a case! Problem solved.

  • Scott Young

    @ frustrated: Seeing how the iPhone is Android’s biggest competitor, we feel we should keep you informed on the larger issues with it. roughly 5 out of our 262 articles the past month has been primarily about the iPhone, so thats about 2%. Any good competitor keeps an eye on it’s competition ;)

  • ben

    I think this is great … Just shows you how apple really has no idea of what they are doing and are starting to struggle in the industry. Pretty retarded of a company to not even test a device …

  • StingRay

    but how does one tell the difference between the loss of signal because the user has bridged the antennae and simply crappy AT&T coverage? Putting a case on won’t solve that…

  • ben

    The hardware issue is logical … I could see why they would be in curing that issue. But yes … It is at&t …

  • Dustin Karnes

    @Stingray There is a video in the link in the first paragraph showing, in real time, The iPhone having great signal until it is held in a way that bridges the two antennas. :)

  • ben

    Yup … Not very smartly engineered haha. Just humorous to me. Go buy a real phone. Android/blackberry!!

  • Sumyunguy

    I think they obviously knew about the issue. Why else would El Jobso have mentioned the specially designed bumper (and for $30!!!)? He has never mentioned a case previously. Only the silly sock.

    They have never had an apple branded case before that I can recall. They always relied upon third party cases like Belkin and InCase.

    Interestingly you posted the picture of Medvedev holding the phone. I found the picture of Jobs holding the phone more interesting! http://www.coated.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/06/steve-jobs-iphone.jpg Notice how Steve is holding the phone to prevent any possible antenna interference????

  • Shane

    This article is pretty hyppocritical.

    You accuse Apple of creating this antenna design based solely on speculation, but aren’t you speculating by making that comment? How do you know what kind of testing they did or didn’t do. How do you know it’s not a firmware issue? How do you know if the final production units from Foxconn varied from the test units?

    You don’t know what you’re talking about. Just stick with the facts of a story and leave your guesses at home.

  • http://www.twitter.com/michaelklurfeld Michael

    I can’t imagine Apple missed the reception issue due to laziness. After all, they really make only a handful of products, and they present the new model once a year. Given the necessity for Apple’s revenue stream to make consumers want to get the new model during each release in the product’s lifeline, it’s hard to believe that they would just get lazy.

    I think the real culprit is the cult of secrecy Apple breeds in its employees. As you said, cellular reception was chiefly done off site, and at those times the thing was in a special case. The other issue is that the bridging of the antennae is something which occurs when you’re holding the phone-left handed, and at that in a particular way. There aren’t that many lefties in the world, right?

    Finally, @Shane:
    I’m going to disagree with how you think hypocrisy works. If someone disapproves of a serial killer’s use of weapons to kill hundreds of innocent children and then takes a glock to a firing range, would you call him a hypocrite because he’s using a gun?

  • http://appsnail.com/iphone/ Ron Wayne

    Hey! this googletv idea is really very interesting how does anybody gets a shot to beta test this does any1 here know? 10x! appreciate any guidance.