Latest Android news, applications and forum discussion

Oct

10

2010

Smartphone docks – are they becoming extinct?

by Steve Ginter
tagged , , ,

There was once a time when it was normal for your pocketable gadget to come with a dock or cradle.  It was a sweet addition to the packaging and was not only very useful for charging and/or syncing your electronic toy, but provided a convenient to way to view your device alongside your monitor, or even by your bedside.  So it comes as a mystery to me why most phones no longer come with a handy dandy dock?

The likely cause of this slow extinction is probably due to manufacturers wanting to cut costs so they can gain higher profit margins.  Ok fine, maybe on the budget devices this makes sense, but for the power users a dock is a godsend.  Being able to just lock, drop, and dock it when you got home or to the office was the pimp thing to do.  Your phone had a home, you knew where it was, and it was always getting charged.

Now we are forced to fiddle with cables dangling on our desks or hanging from a power outlet on the wall – all nonchallant and messy.  Manufacturers are even starting to put the charging ports on the sides and tops of our phones – making it nearly impossible for 3rd-party manufacturers to build a dock should you want one.

In this fast paced race of new smartphones being released every few months, you would think that manufacturers would throw in a little extra to give their devices a bit of an edge in the competition.  Especially since all you would need for a simple dock is a piece of plastic with a micro-usb pass-through.  What are your thoughts on docks and cradles?  Is it an unnecessary waste of desk space – or a required utility to our smartphone way of life.

» See more articles by Steve Ginter

Categorized as Android Rants

Comments

  • George

    Agreed. I recently got Droid 2′s for me and my wife, and I also got us each a dock. It makes a big difference to have a regular place for it, and being able to see it without picking it up is a big functionality for both of us,

  • Mikka Burrell

    Awesome article Steve! I agree, I miss having a dock as an already included accessory. I actually went out and bought a multimedia dock for my Droid 2 and I love it! It’s a great alarm clock (which is a necessity in college! :P ) and I can make calls with it easily on speaker phone as well as take it off easily to text if needed. Some people might not think it’s a ‘required’ utility, but I definitely love having a dock for its convenience. Plus it just looks cool! :)

  • Mrwirez

    What’s missing is a pure GOOGLE Phone. A phone that comes with SU permissions, UN-layered without a trace of the carriers AND vanilla Android with updates sent directly from Google.. The Nexus II -if you will. Verizon, Motorola and HTC are going to ruin Android.. At this point I wouldn’t trade in my Droid1 for anything. I wish Google would light up some fiber and start their own network.. Hell, a jail-broken iphone is looking good again.

    The Docks I can live without, PURE Android … I can’t.

  • Dave

    Absolutely agree. The one reason I never regretted getting a Nexus One. Comes with 2 of them. One for home and one for the car. How useless is a device with GPS when you can’t even dock it? All android devices should come with car docks for that matter.

  • The_Omega_Man

    I have a dock in my bedroom, in my office at work and at home and in the car. It is totally worth it in my opinion.

  • tom p

    i have the rock dock for the mytouch 3g
    gotta say its priceless, as i can use my phone as a radio, etc, especially at night

  • Brad

    I wish I could find any dock for my Incredible

  • Kelly

    I have a Samsung Epic from Sprint. Very nice device, but no dock/cradle. What I really hate, though, is the charging port is on the TOP of the phone! What were they thinking?!?

    Not only does this make the phone useless even for a generic dock, try talking with the charger plugged in. The cord sticks straight up in the air. I’m deaf in my right ear, and when using the phone while plugged in and driving, the cord wants to cover my face to reach from my left ear to the power outlet!

    Stupid ideas like this make me wonder how a company like Samsung could let a dysfunctional design idea travel through all the channels, and EVER make it into the final products. Ugh! Were they even thinking?

    Another shortcoming is no basic sync software…NONE…NADA. At least Motorola and HTC supply basic software to sync Outlook contacts and calendar. Samsung…absolutely nothing. Thanks guys, you just gave me an extra task to set up and perform throughout the day. Never had to before, but now I know every new contact/calendar entry will result in a 2-3 step process to get all the information on my PC and phone.

    Finally, Samsung…in their infinite wisdom…now makes me CHOOSE between having the phone connected to my PC in “charging mode”, or having a wired data connection between my phone and PC. With the Epic, it’s one or the other.

    With a data connection to the pc, the phone is rapidly losing battery power. This is because these tasks (which now have to be done manually) have to run when the phone has no external power supply. Simple tasks like synchronization and data transfer, can only happen when the phone is DISCONNECTED from a power source. These tasks are usually configured to run automatically with most smartphones (transferring or syncing media, contacts, tasks, calendars) are now a redundant and repetitive process.

    You’re free to skip all this if you don’t mind that your PC and phone will contain very different data and information. In charging mode, I might as well forget connecting to the PC, and just plug it in the wall.

    The 2nd and 3rd points are just more examples of features complete lacking intuitiveness and a true understanding of how many people need these devices to perform. This that seems odd for such high-end devices, and for manufacturers trying to survive an intense lineup of competitive offerings to cut corners that result in making their phone less useful that a 10-year-old Motorola Flip Phone.

    For all its shortcomings and limitations, Apple really hit the mark with an intuitive, user-friendly device, that had all the functionality we should expect from a smart phone.

    Samsung made a wonderful device inthe Epic, but virtually offset all of its advantages by leaving out basic utilities, cutting corners by not including the most basic of docks, and the ridiculous port placement. This nothing by new work for customers, and repetitive and time-consuming.

    So much for the extra freedom we hoped to get from a high-performing new smart phone.

    I’m still within my 30-day trial, and might jump to the Droid X or Evo, simply because they have Outlook sync software designed into their phones, simply to make life easier for any Outlook user.

    Plus, I HATE having to contstantly jump back and forth to charge/data connect to my pc. Jeez, would it kill you Samsung to incorporate these like virtually every smartphone made since 2000.

    Thanks for those changes. Nothing about them makes sense, and they make a multi-faceted device more of a pain in the ass than my 1st generation iPaq from 1998. Now I have to make accomodations and take multiple steps to perform what’s always been the most basic of tasks.

    Kinda like having the most advanced sports car ever made…but some new drawbacks…(1) Requiring TWO keys to start, (2) forcing drivers to choose between running the AC or the stereo (but NOT at the same time), and (3) placing the gas cap so we need to insert the pump directly next to the oil drain plug!

  • http://turtlecc.com/ Lou Droid

    Agree. I bought my wife a docking (droid) station for her office and she in turn bought me a car dock for my Droid X. (she spends her time in an office me on the road)

    to the point of the article though….I doubt many of us would change the phone we get based on a docking station being included in the package. Manufactures of course are aware.