Judge Lucy Koh Orders Key Samsung Designer To Zip It, Bans Her From Testifying In Apple Vs. Samsung Suit

by Roy Alugbue on
tagged , , ,

 

As the Apple vs. Samsung saga continues on, the courts continue to lay the smackdown on Samsung. Judge Lucy Koh recently signed a document which bars Samsung designer Hyong Shin Park from testifying in the courtroom. Park is quoted as saying Samsung’s phones were inspired by a “bowl of water” as opposed to the iPhone. Samsung adds by explaining Park’s design patent dates back to December 2006, which is well-before when Apple launched its first iPhone. Apple on the other hand, countered by arguing her project, the F700, isn’t in the list of accused phones (i.e. the Galaxy S), and that Park’s testimony isn’t relevant to the case. In addition, the Cupertino giant has also argued that her testimony isn’t relevant because she didn’t design any of the products it says copied the iPhone’s look and feel.

Despite the major setback for Samsung, the lawsuit continues on today. As the epic trial comes to a close, the hope is that there will be some sort of resolution or compromise so the two companies can finally move on.

source: CNet

 

 

 

 

 

» See more articles by Roy Alugbue


Categorized as Android Lawsuits, Android Manufacturers, Android Phones, Android Tablets

  • Flirty_Girl

    > Park is quoted as saying Samsung’s phones were
    > inspired by a “bowl of water”

    Why would I want to buy a phone design that was inspired by a large bowl of water????

    • bean cube

      Be like water, my friends.

      Water has all kinds of shapes that primitive human languages can’t depict yet. Even after boiling, water condenses back into liquid. Water sustains lives and evolves civilizations and flows. We wash ourselves with it all the time and we may even use water in nano technology as fuel very soon.

  • Mei

    Everyone is going to know who this “Judge Lucy Koh” is when this case is over. And based on the outcome of this case, they will know how fair and impartial she is, and whether she made sound judgements and decisions that is to be expected from a ‘sensible’ and ‘wise’ judge. This single case can define her whole career especially if she makes bad rulings. She better watch herself, reframe from being biased, and most of all keep her ego in check.

  • cooldoods

    Of course Park’s testimony is relevant, her design is part of Samsung’s design portfolio which precedes the iPhone. It would show that Samsung was working on rectangular devices with full touchscreens and rounded corners and a single home button before the iPhone.

  • me

    Oh Lucy, so you don’t get designer’s opinion on how their design works? Then you decided to ban them for that ? Wow..