Latest Android news, applications and forum discussion

Aug

15

2010

How Android will beat Windows Phone 7

10

by Chris Moor
tagged , , , , , , ,

The holiday season is steadily approaching and with that comes the launch of Windows Phone 7 - Microsoft’s answer to Android – which debuts in October. While Android will go into battle with a full head of steam, WP7 is sure to make an impact in the market. Whether or not Android will be able to continue to gain momentum is something only time can tell. What I can tell you though is that if Google wants to slay this giant they need to continue to develop exclusive features like the new voice actions and separate themselves from the competition. After the break, I’ll explain what areas will play big roles in the battle for smartphone OS supremacy.

Now Microsoft hasn’t exactly been the most innovative company over the past several years but they are still humongous. And there were changes made in Redmond recently. So don’t sleep on Windows Phone 7, it’s got some things going for it. Microsoft has aggressively made sure that all WP7 phones feel very similar to the user. Minimum system requirements are more strict than Android’s and the UI will not be skinned by the manufacturer. This will ensure a high quality end product that operates exactly the same as every other WP7 phone. While Google intended customizable UI’s  to be a feature for manufacturers who want to separate their product from the competition it has been more of a hindrance in reality. This is all expected to change with Android 3.0 Gingerbread. System requirements will be bumped up to a minimum 1 GHz processor and 512 MB RAM, identical to WP7 for these two aspects. Also the UI is getting an overhaul and custom skins will be a thing of the past. So goodbye to MotoBlur and HTC Sense, I’m sure only one of you will be missed. Jokes aside, the UI will be a deciding factor in this battle. Microsoft has opted away from the application grid seen on most smartphones and created a new tile scheme. Early impressions have been good and the tight controls are said to be on par with the best of current devices. Gingerbread will need it’s UI to be as attractive and responsive if they want to continue to grow in the market.

Media consumption is another area WP7 focuses heavily on, in particular gaming and music.

Notable gaming features include integrated Xbox Live and the ability to transfer progress made in a game between PC, Phone, and Xbox. At this point, as far as gaming is concerned emulation is really the only thing Android has going for it. This is nothing to sneeze at I know but many consumers will never exploit it. As flash integration furthers gaming should improve some but Google needs to find a way to get developers making games for Android. Hopefully Android 3.0 will be the last upgrade we see for a while and developers don’t have to worry about making sure their app runs on all the different versions of Android out there.

Music and video is another feature Microsoft has focused on. WP7 essentially has a Zune HD inside of it. This is no doubt a major step above Android’s stock media player. Apps are available to improve this but Google knows they need to take the reins themselves here. The forthcoming streaming music service shows Google’s dedication to high quality and innovative media consumption. So I feel this issue will be addressed just fine.

I’ll conclude this article by saying Android will have an edge over Windows Phone 7 from day one and I feel it will be their game to lose. WP7 won’t get flash integration until a couple of months after launch and it does not support multitasking. If Google continue’s to bring new features to Android they should continue to see sales go up. Comment with your thoughts.

This has been an original article by Brett Clapper. Follow me on twitter @baclap. Send comments and tips to clapperbrett@gmail.com.

» See more articles by Chris Moor

Categorized as Android Development, Android News, Android Phones

Comments

  • ac

    “custom skins will be a thing of the past. So goodbye to MotoBlur and HTC Sense”

    This turned out to be a false rumor

  • Nortisan

    @ac… True… However, whether it’s related somewhat to Android 3.0 Gingerbread or not, Motorola HAS decided to cease development and implementation of Motoblur on future devices. And who knows, HTC may eventually decide to follow suit once they see what Gingerbread has in store when they get their hands on it.

  • Mickey Jones

    Why would anyone want to extend the MS monopoly of the desktop over to mobile platforms? NO THANKS.

    MS has a habit of bailing on projects like PlaysForSure, Urge, Kin etc that don’t become quickly profitable. Frankly MS has to EARN the right to be on my phone and that will take time and innovation.

  • ari-free

    First of all, WP7′s UI is beyond ugly. Icons look like traffic signs: only 2 colors and the other color is white. Titles are in big lowercase letters and don’t even fit the screen.
    2) Don’t expect games like Gears of War on your WP7 phone. There’s no NDK and everything must be in managed code. Managed code is fine for 90% of apps but it is the other 10% that are the most interesting.
    3) no support for asian languages means this is DOA in most of the countries that will actually make this phone.

  • Jesse

    I think Android might be in a little bit of trouble to be honest. Right now they basically have no competition in the smartphone market on every carrier except ATT. Motorolla, HTC, Samsung, Dell, all of them have tried to make the interface better and offer exclusive features but in the end all they have succeded in doing is making the OS different across the platform, perform badly, ugly and hard to upgrade.

    You constantly hear about upgrades for phones and then about delays. Phones you buy on day one are either already out of date or will be in a matter of weeks. Apps, are hard to sell and maintain and virtually impossible to target to the Android community due to fragmentation. Android is mess plain and simple, as both a user and developer I know I can’t wait for something else to come take its place.

  • http://www.Twitter.com/QDOG8 QDOG8

    When you said that “Gingerbread” will make companies not want to make custom skins over Android, does that mean that already skined nex-gen phones, like the DROID x, won’t get Android 3.0?

  • Ben

    Voice features are exclusive to android? Have you used Windows mobile 4-6.5 They all had voice commands and a voice command Api for third party apps, Google is late to that game. Not to mention that as much as I like finally having voice commands on my android phone its not quite as good as windows mobiles was, but close. (IMO)

  • ari-free

    jesse: they have plenty of competition from WinMo and blackberry on every carrier. Android is also winning overseas where it faces nokia/symbian and iphone on every carrier.

  • Shirley

    The clean and unified interface and the way they have avoided the over reliance on independant apps is what has impressed me – totally unlike something Microsoft would come up with to be honest.

    However, the multi-tasking thing is bizarre – I know they’ve allowed it for native apps (like Word, Excel, OneNote and Zune), but why not 3rd Party apps?

    But going back to the interface, I kind of understand why tiles and Titles are half off the screen – it’s a way of indicating that there is more screen real-estate beyond the physical screen – kind of clever and inutuitive imho – and quite a modern aesthestic – I know those who favour symmetry will hate it! lol.#

    If it didn’t have text and pictures cut off, how would you intuitively show that you could scroll to the side or up and down? have arrows everywhere?

    I hope Gingerbread totally rethinks the interface, because at the moment Android and iOS look ‘old’

  • http://www.themedicaltranscriptionistblog.com/ Chantay Firsching

    wanted to let you know that your website doesnt load properly when using safari. thought I should let you know